Ride in a gondola/traghetto/vaporetto.
I originally wanted to ride a gondola just like every other American tourist ever. But I started reading about the downsides of gondola rides (they're expensive! you don't cover a lot of ground! the canals are smelly!), and I've decided that as long as I get to travel by water, I don't necessarily mind if it's not in a gondola. Besides, we're not romantical-types anyway. We don't need our own personal Italian singer. Apparently traghettos and vaporettos are much more common for getting around.

See a performance at Teatro La Fenice.
"The City of Falling Angels" was set in 1996, and centered around when this opera house burned down for the second time. The book created in me this fascination with the building and its history. The famous, majestic opera house has since been re-built (again), and I think it would be so cool to experience an performance — be it an opera, a ballet, or a concert — there. (Though to be honest, I'd prefer to see an opera. In Italian.)
Eat at Antica Adelaide.
My family has always been big on trying local cuisines and restaurants, and even when we're home, we rarely eat at chains. So the same holds true for me when I go on vacation — I want to eat what the locals are eating, and experience how they do things. Antica Adelaide is an authentic Venetian restaurant that doesn't seem like they cater much to tourists: the restaurant is kind of tucked away off a canal, the meals are meant for two, they change the menu depending on the seasonal availability of ingredients (love that!) and are highly rated by locals. Of course there's fresh pasta on their menu, though I would be open to other foods and experiences!
Go on the Venice Ghost Walking Tour.
Sometimes I'm a fan of tours and sometimes I'm not. In the past, I've done tours that haven't been worth the time, and I've also done tours that totally made the trip. So if I'm going to go on a tour, I want it to be something that I wouldn't get a chance to experience if I simply read guidebooks or websites. I think this ghost-walking tour fits the bill — a chance to hear some local ghost stories, as well as a reason to get off the beaten path? Sign me up!
Order amaretto gelato at Gelateria Nico.
Because no trip to Italy would be complete without gelato! This place is supposedly the best in Venice. Amaretto gelato would be ideal, but really ... I just love ice cream, so any flavor is acceptable! They sell big sundaes as well as individual scoops, and based on the picture below, I'd probably stick to just a scoop, or else Matt would be rolling me out the door!
Have you been to Venice? What would you love to do if you went?